Spat Over Bryant’s Comments On Unity Referendum

Row over Secretary of State’s comments on the unity referendum

Sir Chris Bryant, Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, has come under flackAs the from Sinn Féin for comments on the prospect of a border poll.

As the Assembly election nudges closer, Unionist/Loyalist and Nationalist/Republican parties are digging in for what looks like another election based on tribal loyalties.

Unity referendum not a concession to be gifted by any British politician says Murphy

Speaking in response to comments by British Secretary of State, Chris Bryant on Morning Ireland on a border poll, Sinn Féin Senator Conor Murphy said;

“The two governments are co-guarantors of the Good Friday Agreement. They have an obligation to implement its provisions – including the unity referendum provisions of the Agreement.

Sinn Féin Senator Conor Murphy locks horns with the Secretary of State over the right to call a unity referendum.

“The unity referendums are not a concession to be gifted to the people of Ireland by any British politician. They are a legal entitlement enshrined in the Good Friday Agreement.

“The proposals announced by both the Taoiseach and Tanaiste in recent weeks recognise the political reality that momentum is growing on the issue of the national question, which is welcome and a significant and constructive contribution.

“Ambition must now be matched by action, including open dialogue with the British government.”

Secretary of State has answered the border poll question again says UUP Leader Jon Burrows

Ulster Unionist Party Leader Jon Burrows MLA has welcomed the Secretary of State’s restatement of the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement’s test for a border poll, and said Dublin’s focus at today’s British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference should be on its own responsibilities.

Jon Burrows MLA said: “This morning Sir Chris Bryant was asked the same question again and again, and he gave the same answer each time, because it is the only answer the Agreement allows.

UUP Leader Jon Burrows says that the conditions for a unity referendum need to be met in the GFA and don’t look likely at present.

“A border poll can only be called when it appears likely that a majority would vote to leave the United Kingdom. He has said plainly that he does not detect that, and neither will anyone who looks honestly at the evidence.

“He was equally clear that the decision rests with the Secretary of State, and that both governments, as co-guarantors, have agreed that. Dublin signed up to it in 1998. Asking the question a fourth or fifth time on the radio does not change it.

“In September I said the pressure on the Secretary of State to rewrite or dilute that test had to stop. Today he held the line again, and I commend him for it.

“The Irish Government has real responsibilities of its own, not least to the Omagh families who are still waiting for a commitment to an Irish inquiry. That is where its attention should be today.

“For everyone else, the question that matters is not a border poll that isn’t coming. It is whether Stormont can agree a budget and get on with fixing public services. That is what people expect us to be talking about.”

On the GFA

The Good Friday Agreement (Belfast Agreement) states that a unity referendum (“border poll”) in Northern Ireland must be called by the UK Secretary of State for Northern Ireland if it appears likely that a simple majority of those voting would support leaving the UK to form a united Ireland.

Any move to a united Ireland also requires majority consent in both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

Calling a Referendum

  • The Trigger Mechanism: The Secretary of State is legally required to call a poll if it becomes “likely” that a simple majority of voters would choose a united Ireland. [1, 2]
  • Assessment & Timing: The agreement does not specify a rigid mathematical formula for “likely,” leaving the determination to the Secretary of State based on indicators such as polling trends, election outcomes, and demographics. By law, polls cannot be held more frequently than once every seven years. [1, 2]
  • Dual Consent: Unification can only occur if agreed to by concurrent majority votes in both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. [1, 2, 3]

Approval and Consent

Therefore, it appears the decision lies solely with the Secretary of State according to the legislation of the Good Friday Agreement. It will be never-the-less a subjective decision by the Secretary of State if and when it comes.

This begs the question: what lessons from the Brexit Referendum can we learn that will prevent future political, economic and social chaos across the board ?

All parties may have to revise their ideologies as we face external existential perils across Europe and farther afield.

If Northern Ireland and the ROI voted for Irish unity, NI would then be part of the EU again but its trading relationship with Britain would again be tenuous. That could be a lose-lose scenario.

And again, begging the question, are preparations substantial enough to harmonise the North and South into one homogeneous, political body ? Have both governments shown flexibility and willingness in daring to prepare for integration ?

The politicians need to re-think their way out of the complexity of UK and Irish history and look at the wider exigencies they are facing such as climate change, energy, a changing global politics, and specifically at a US that has become unpredictable.

It is an immensely complicated problem that requires leadership of the highest degree.

Hot this week

- Advertisements -

Related Articles

USPCA Has Concerns As Animal Welfare Issues Rise

 Animal welfare concerns rise say USPCAThe number of reports relating to animal welfare concerns and investigative activity has increased almost 175% in the past...

Muir Prepares For A Round Of Pet Protection Legislation

Animal welfare reforms to deliver strong protections for pets says MuirDAERA Minister Andrew Muir has confirmed plans to ban the use of handheld remote-controlled...

The Late Kieran Devlin Remembered

Kieran Devlin: a gentle giant who was a true Outlaw biker at heart has passed awayThe requiem mass for the late Kieran Devlin (55)...

Popular Categories